E-Commerce

How to Price a Product Online: Unit Economics for Indian Sellers

How to Price a Product Online: Unit Economics for Indian Sellers
UNIT ECONOMICS How to Price a Product Online What Survives the Fees blogshog.com

Price from the bottom up: start with every cost per unit including returns, add the margin you need, and only then check whether that number is competitive. The common sequence is the reverse — look at what competitors charge, match it, and discover months later that each sale loses money once commission, shipping, packaging, payment charges and returns are counted.

The reason this catches so many sellers is that the costs are individually small and collectively decisive. A commission here, a shipping charge there, a payment gateway percentage, GST handled incorrectly, one return in fifteen — none looks significant and together they routinely consume the whole apparent margin.

What are all the costs per unit?

Build this list once, in a spreadsheet, for your best-selling product. It takes an hour and it is the most useful hour available to a small online seller.

Everything that comes out of one sale DIRECT PRODUCT COSTS Purchase or manufacturing cost per unitNet of input GST credit if registered Inward freight and handlingOften forgotten entirely Packaging: box, filler, tape, labelAdd it up per parcel, not per roll CHANNEL COSTS Marketplace commissionVaries by category, check yours Fulfilment or closing feesSometimes a flat fee per order Shipping, by weight slab and zoneVolumetric weight can exceed actual Payment gateway or COD collection feeCOD usually costs more than prepaid THE ONES PEOPLE OMIT Return cost spread across all units sold Advertising spend per order, and write-offs for damaged stock

The two lines at the bottom are the ones that turn a positive sheet negative. Returns must be amortised across every unit sold, not treated as an occasional misfortune: if one order in fifteen comes back and a return costs you more than a sale earns, that is a per-unit cost on all fifteen. Our piece on returns and RTO explains how to calculate the figure to plug in here.

Volumetric weight deserves a specific warning. Couriers charge on whichever is higher, actual weight or volumetric weight calculated from the parcel’s dimensions. A light but bulky product — a cushion, a lampshade, anything with air in the box — is often billed at two or three times its real weight, and sellers who priced on actual weight discover this in their first monthly invoice.

A walkthrough of product pricing strategy and the costs to build in.

How do you handle GST in the price?

The single most common pricing error among new Indian sellers is treating the price a customer pays as revenue. It is not: if you are GST-registered, the listed price is inclusive of GST, and the tax portion is not yours. You are collecting it and paying it on.

The price the customer pays is not your revenue What the customer pays Listed price, GST inclusive How it splits Your taxable value — this is what you work with GST — not yours Build margin on the taxable value, and remember input credit reduces your real product cost

Two consequences follow. First, calculate your margin on the taxable value rather than the sticker price, or you will overstate it by the GST rate on every single unit. Second, if you are registered you can usually claim input credit on what you paid for the goods and on many of your business expenses, which reduces your effective cost — so a registered seller and an unregistered one have genuinely different economics on the same product.

Marketplaces also deduct tax at source on your supplies, which affects cash flow rather than profit but is worth modelling. The mechanics, registration thresholds and return filing are covered in our guide to GST for online sellers in India, and the rules change often enough that it is worth confirming the current position with your accountant.

What is a break-even price?

The price at which a unit contributes nothing. Knowing it changes how you behave during sales and festival discounting, because it tells you exactly where discounting stops being a customer-acquisition decision and starts being a donation.

Work it out in this order AProduct cost, net of input credit, plus inward freight BPlus packaging per parcel CPlus shipping at the correct weight slab and zone DPlus amortised return cost per unit sold EDivide by (1 minus commission % minus payment fee %) =Your break-even taxable price. Add GST for the listed price, then add your margin.

Step E is the one people get arithmetically wrong. Commission is a percentage of the selling price, not of your cost, so you cannot simply add it to the cost stack — you have to divide by what remains after the percentage charges. Adding instead of dividing understates the required price, and the error grows with the commission rate.

Once you have the floor, write it on the sheet in bold. During a festival sale, when a marketplace pushes you to discount and competitors are cutting prices, that number is the only thing standing between participating in a sale and funding one.

Cost-plus, value-based and competitive pricing explained for beginners.

Should you price on cost, competitors or value?

Three approaches, and when each fits Cost-plus Costs plus a target margin Use it as a floor Simple and safe, but ignores what buyers would willingly pay Competitive Match or undercut rivals Dangerous alone Their costs are not yours. They may be losing money too. Value-based What it is worth to the buyer Where margin lives Needs differentiation: a brand, a guarantee, a bundle, better service

Use cost-plus to find the floor and value-based to find the ceiling, and let competitive pricing inform rather than decide. The trap in a crowded Indian marketplace category is assuming the lowest-priced competitor knows something you do not; frequently they are selling at a loss to buy ranking, and following them down is how a category becomes unprofitable for everyone in it.

If you are stuck matching prices on an identical commodity product, the real problem is the product rather than the price. Bundling, a longer warranty, faster dispatch or genuinely better listings are all ways out; cutting another two per cent is not.

How do you handle advertising cost?

If you advertise, the money spent to generate an order is a cost of that order and belongs in the unit economics. The number to watch is advertising spend divided by the revenue it generated — and the honest version of that calculation includes the orders that advertising did not generate, not just the ones it is credited with.

Two practical rules. Check your advertising cost against your contribution margin, not your gross margin: if a product contributes a small amount per unit after all costs, the sustainable advertising spend is a fraction of that, and spending the full contribution to acquire an order means working for nothing. And distinguish products you advertise to acquire customers from products you expect to be profitable immediately, because those are different jobs and different acceptable spends.

For a repeat-purchase product, acquiring a customer at a loss on the first order can be entirely rational — provided you actually know your repeat rate rather than assuming one.

A practical pricing method for retail and wholesale, with the margin maths.

A one-hour exercise

  1. Pick your best-selling product and open a spreadsheet.
  2. List every cost from the table above with real numbers from your last invoices, not estimates.
  3. Calculate your return rate for that product and amortise the return cost across units sold.
  4. Compute the break-even taxable price using division for the percentage fees, not addition.
  5. Compare it to what you currently charge. A meaningful number of sellers discover a bestseller is their least profitable item.
  6. Repeat for your three worst-margin products and decide whether to reprice, repackage or discontinue each.
  7. Write the floor price on the sheet and keep it open during sale events.

Step five is where this exercise earns its keep. The product that sells most is often the one priced most aggressively, and volume on a thin or negative contribution feels like success while quietly funding itself from your other products. Knowing the per-unit numbers is what lets you tell growth from churn.

Pricing sits downstream of several other decisions. Returns and RTO determines one of your biggest cost lines, listing quality determines whether you can hold a higher price, and GST registration changes the economics outright. If you are choosing where to sell, Amazon India seller fees and Shopify vs WooCommerce cover the channel costs, and how to start an online store in India is the overview. More in the business and technology section.

What costs do online sellers most often forget?

Amortised return costs, advertising spend per order, inward freight, packaging counted per parcel, and volumetric weight on shipping. Returns are the most damaging omission, because they must be spread across every unit sold rather than treated as an occasional misfortune.

What is volumetric weight and why does it matter?

Couriers charge on whichever is higher, actual weight or a volumetric weight calculated from the parcel’s dimensions. A light but bulky item such as a cushion or lampshade is often billed at several times its real weight, which surprises sellers who priced using actual weight.

Is the price a customer pays my revenue?

No, if you are GST-registered. The listed price is GST-inclusive and the tax portion is collected on behalf of the government. Calculate margin on the taxable value, or you will overstate it by the GST rate on every unit sold.

How do I account for marketplace commission in the price?

By division, not addition. Commission is a percentage of the selling price rather than of your cost, so you divide your cost stack by one minus the percentage charges. Adding the commission to costs understates the price you need, and the error grows with the commission rate.

Should I match my competitors’ prices?

Use competitor prices as information, not as the decision. Their costs are not yours and some are deliberately selling at a loss to buy ranking, so following them down can make a whole category unprofitable. Find your floor from costs and your ceiling from the value you offer.

How much can I afford to spend on advertising per order?

A fraction of your contribution margin after all costs, not your gross margin. Spending the entire contribution to acquire an order means working for nothing. Acquiring at a loss can be rational for a genuine repeat-purchase product, but only if you know your actual repeat rate.

Why do my bestsellers sometimes lose money?

Because the product that sells most is often the one priced most aggressively, and high volume on a thin or negative contribution looks like success while being funded by your other products. Running the per-unit numbers for each product is what distinguishes growth from churn.